Trump exposes UN hypocrisy on PLO, Hamas and Israel
President Trump has challenged United Nations (UN) member States to put their money where their mouths are in a hard-hitting speech delivered by US Permanent Representative to the UN – Ambassador Nikki Haley – at a UN Security Council Open Debate on the Middle East on 24 July.
Following Trump’s dressing down of NATO– Haley attacked UN member States who are full of words but short on money when it comes to supporting the Palestinian Arabs.
Haley did not mince her words:
Here at the UN, thousands of miles away from Palestinians who do have real needs, there is no end to the speeches on their behalf. Country after country claims solidarity with the Palestinian people. If those words were useful in the schools, the hospitals, and the streets of their communities, the Palestinian people would not be facing the desperate conditions we are discussing here today. Talk is cheap.
No group of countries is more generous with their words than the Palestinians’ Arab neighbors, and other OIC [Organisation of Islamic Cooperation – ed.]member states. But all of the words spoken here in New York do not feed, clothe, or educate a single Palestinian child. All they do is get the international community riled up.
Haley used members’ contributions to UNRWA to prove her case:
Last year, Iran’s contribution to UNRWA was zero. Algeria’s contribution to UNRWA was zero. Tunisia’s contribution to UNRWA was zero.
Other countries did provide some funding. Pakistan gave $20,000. Egypt gave $20,000. Oman gave $668,000.
Haley did not spare non-Arab and non-Islamic countries from similar naming and shaming:
Other countries talk a big game about the Palestinian cause. In 2017, China provided $350,000 to UNRWA. Russia provided two million dollars to UNWRA.
Haley contrasted America’s generosity:
Last year … the United States gave 364 million dollars… And that’s on top of what the American people give annually to the Palestinians in bilateral assistance. That is another 300 million dollars just last year, and it averages to more than a quarter of a billion dollars every year since 1993.
Haley delivered this stern warning:
“But we are not fools. If we extend a hand in friendship and generosity, we do not expect our hand to be bitten. And as we extend our hand, we also expect others to extend their hands as well.”
Haley emphasised that Arab countries’ giving more money was not the only issue confronting them:
Too often, the Arab countries give just enough money and mouth just enough uncompromising words to stay out of the crosshairs of Palestinian representatives. But if they really cared about the Palestinian people, they would not do that. Instead, they would condemn extremism and they would put forth serious ideas for compromises that could end this struggle and lead to a better life for the Palestinian people. They would tell the Palestinian leadership how foolish they look for condemning a peace proposal [Trumps’ “ultimate deal” – ed.]they haven’t even seen yet.
Haley called out both aberrant PLO and Hamas leaderships:
The Palestinian leadership has been allowed to live a false reality for too long because Arab leaders are afraid to tell them the truth… It is time for the regional states in particular to step up and really help the Palestinian people, instead of just making speeches thousands of miles away.
Those regional States – Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon – can really help by sitting down with Israel and negotiating an end to the 100-years old Arab-Jewish conflict as formulated 51 years ago by UN Security Council Resolution 242.
Delivering this message to the UN has been long overdue.
David Singer is a Sydney Lawyer and Foundation Member of the International Analysts Network
Author’s note: The cartoon – commissioned exclusively for this article—is by Yaakov Kirschen aka “Dry Bones”- one of Israel’s foremost political and social commentators – whose cartoons have graced the columns of Israeli and international media publications for decades. His cartoons can be viewed at Drybonesblog
Well done David : Haley stating the obvious is a great first step
In the change process – hopefully !
NATO and the UN (especially UNRWA) need a radical rewrite/review/overhaul
– they are
Dinosaur agencies with a use-by date – in full bloom of failure at the moment.
How utterly comforting (I don’t think ) that Nikki Haley has to
Reprimand then talk up then surreptitiously threaten Arab states about
Caring for their brethren! How utterly disgusting.
How utterly disgraceful that these Arab states are not only
Negligent but TRUMP needs to remind them of their negligence .
How utterly delusional and fractured is the world that they CONTINUE
To deny Israel’s legitimacy and goodwill.
How utterly USELESS Haley’s words will be UNLESS Trump, once
Again bestowes upon ALL stakeholder Arab nations a new set of
Fiscal sanctions and makes it VERY CLEAR that new rules will apply.
Erica
One thing is clear – President Trump will not be pouring hundreds of millions of dollars down the PLO’s bottomless pit.
Hopefully he might be persuaded to send an equivalent amount to Israel to compensate Israeli victims of terrorist attacks emanating from Gaza and Areas “A” and “B” in Judea and Samaria.
It will probably not be too long before Trump also takes decisive action to close down The General Delegation of the Palestine Liberation Organization to the United States.
Making a fool of President Trump by writing off his peace plan before its contents are even known – and crowing about it – is as irresponsible as the PLO can get.