Israel’s dysfunctional Government cannot survive
An amalgam of eight leaders trading insults and denigrating each other – whilst their parties have adopted policies that are totally irreconcilable on critical issues – is not the foundation for any stable Government – especially in Israel – whose enemies will become increasingly emboldened following the announcement of a cobbled-together Israeli Government comprising very different bedfellows.
A vote of confidence first needed from 61 members of the Knesset before this dysfunctional Government even begins operating is certainly not a foregone conclusion.
Either an Islamic-Arab party – Ra’am (4 seats) – or an extreme left-wing party – Meretz (6 seats) which includes two Israeli Arabs – possess the ability to drag Israelis to the fifth election in 3 years.
This Government could implode in making decisions involving such issues as:
- Hauling Israel before the International Criminal Court (ICC)
- Authorising future building in Judea and Samaria (West Bank)
- Extending Israeli sovereignty into Judea and Samaria
- Preventing the renewal of violent protests by Israel’s Arab population that saw synagogues burnt and attacks on Jews and their property during last month’s Israel- Gaza conflict
Fractured relations and policy differences abound:
- Meretz leader – Nitzan Horowitz – has adopted the position that the ICC has grounds for investigating Israel for suspected war crimes.
Gideon Sa’ar – leader of the New Hope party – said that he would not include Meretz in any coalition he led for holding that viewpoint.
“Horowitz can’t join the government with positions like that,”
Yamina MK Ayelet Shaked – echoed Sa’ar’s sentiments:
“Anyone who talks like that will not be with us in a coalition,”
Yet Sa’ar and Shaked – and supposedly 10 other members of New Hope and Yamina parties – are ready to sit with Horowitz in coalition as the ICC probe continues and Israel’s Government has to formulate its responses.
- Prime Minister-elect Bennett repeatedly called Ra’am leader Mansour Abbas a “terror supporter” before the elections – but now opines:
“Mansour Abbas isn’t a terror supporter. I met an honest man and a brave leader who is reaching out and seeking to help Israeli citizens.”
An amazing epiphany indeed for an Arab leader whose party’s 4 seats could bring down this Government at any time.
- During the election campaign – Bennett signed a pledge on TV (pictured below) – making the following commitments:
“I won’t allow Yair Lapid to be prime minister, including in a rotation (agreement.)” and “I will not establish a government based on the support of Mansour Abbas from the Islamic Movement.”
Naphtali Bennett
Bennett’s credibility has been shot to pieces.
- Bennett has long held the following views:
“The central problem is the failure of the Israeli leadership to simply state that the land of Israel belongs to the people of Israel. We have to say this to ourselves on Channel 2 and on CNN that Israel belongs to the Jews”
“We have to tell ourselves and the whole world that his land has belonged to us for 3,000 years. The most certain path to defeat is for Israel to forget its sense of justice. This is true historically and legally. There has never been a Palestinian state here.”
Can Bennett utter one word about these historic and modern-day legal claims without the leaders of Meretz and Ra’am threatening to pack their bags and bring down the Government?
- Bennett has argued since 2012 in his detailed “Israel Stability Initiative” that Israel needs to extend its sovereignty into Area C of Judea and Samaria and that Gaza should be separated from Judea and Samaria. Advancing Bennett’s plan could see the Government’s downfall.
Israelis deserve a Government united in policy and possessing the firm resolve to combat their sworn enemies. This rancour-ridden Government – infected by deep political differences – is not the answer.
David Singer is a Sydney lawyer and a foundation member of the International Analysts Network
Author’s note: The cartoon — commissioned exclusively for this article — is by Yaakov Kirschen aka “Dry Bones”- one of Israel’s foremost political and social commentators — whose cartoons have graced the columns of Israeli and international media publications for decades.
As far as I can see, the patchwork government is not meant to survive. It was most likely stitched together to get rid of Bibi and to then call another election which the religious/right would win and the unhappy status quo would return.
There will be a coalition within the coalition with far left self hating Meretz and Arab party Raam
Imagine their attitude when it comes to dealing with security Israel’s own Arab 5 th columnists and Islamist Palestinians next door
Oy Vay !