Harvard students make time for Arafat, but not for Harvard terror victims…writes Stephen Flatow
The controversy over the Harvard University students who recently posed, smiling, at Yasser Arafat’s grave sent a shot of pain through every one of us who has lost a loved one in the terrorist attacks that Arafat and his allies have waged over the years.
Harvard University students pose at Yasser Arafat’s grave on a recent trip called “Israel Trek” that was sponsored by Harvard Hillel and Combined Jewish Philanthropies of Boston. Credit: Twitter.
But it must have been particularly awful for Dr. Alan Bauer, a Harvard-educated scientist, to see students from his own school smiling and enjoying their visit to the tombstone of the man responsible for the vicious attack that left Bauer and his 7-year-old son permanently maimed.
Bauer and his son Jonathan were walking on King George Street in downtown Jerusalem on March 21, 2002, when a terrorist from Arafat’s Fatah movement blew himself up. His explosive device was packed with metal spikes and nails, in order to inflict the maximum amount of pain and destruction and the defenseless Israeli civilians walking by. Three passersby were killed, 87 were wounded. Dr. Bauer and Jonathan were hit by multiple metal projectiles. Two of the metal spikes penetrated little Jonathan’s brain.
The attack was in the news for a few days, and then it was out of the public’s sight, and out of the public’s mind. Who today remembers Alan and Jonathan Bauer? Certainly not the 50 or so Harvard students who recently visited Israel and the Palestinian Authority-controlled territories, paid for by Combined Jewish Philanthropies (Boston Jewish’s federation) and Harvard Hillel.
I’m sure Alan, as a Harvard alumnus, would have appreciated a friendly visit to his Jerusalem home and a few words of sympathy from the Harvard students. Apparently the tour organizers never bothered to check on whether there are any Harvard graduates among the terror victims in Israel. But don’t put all the blame on the organizers. These students know how to do a little research on the Internet. In a few minutes, they could have learned about Alan and Jonathan. They didn’t make the time to do that.
But they did make the time to pose, grinning, at the gravesite of the man responsible for that Jerusalem bombing and so many other war crimes against the Jewish people. And they were so proud of the photo that they rushed to share it with the world via social media.
I was disappointed to read an article by three Boston Jewish federation officials, declaring that criticism of the Arafat photo-op is “absurd.” The most they would concede is that some of the trip organizers showed “poor judgment,” but they refused to condemn the students’ action. They shouldn’t be treating the students as if they were babies. They are young adults who either knew what they were doing, or should have.
I was equally disappointed to see that Prof. Deborah Lipstadt, on her Facebook page, wrote this about the Jewish officials’ article defending the Harvard students: “What a thoughtful article. Lucky is the community with such thoughtful leader who know how to keep their heads screwed on straight.” As a Holocaust scholar, Prof. Lipstadt, of all people, should be able to recognize Arafat was engaged in the attempted genocide of Israel’s Jews. She should have been as outraged by the Arafat visit, as she would have been if the Harvard students had visited Afghanistan and posed at the grave of an Al-Qaeda leader, or if they went to South Africa and had a giggle-and-selfie fest at the grave of an apartheid regime police officer who tortured or murdered black activists.
Last week marked the 12th anniversary of the bombing that maimed the Bauers. This week is the 19th anniversary of the Palestinian bombing attack in which my daughter Alisa was murdered. She was a student at Brandeis University, just a few miles down the road from Harvard. The students at Harvard have shown as little interest in Alisa as they have in Alan or Jonathan Bauer.
One of the Harvard students, by the name of Kelsey, last week defended her participation in the Arafat grave visit on the grounds that, “Acknowledging one person’s lived experience neither negates nor diminishes another person’s lived experience.”
Actually, Kelsey, you have not at all acknowledged Arafat’s “lived experience”—you did not write anything about the mass murders and maimings he perpetrated. And you have indeed negated and diminished “another person’s lived experience”—you have negated and diminished the suffering of his victims and their families. Until you understand that, you have learned nothing from your years of learning in the prestigious halls of Harvard.
Stephen M. Flatow is an attorney. His 20-year-old daughter Alisa was murdered in a 1995 bus bombing while she was a student in Israel. JNS.org
Dear J-Wire,
There’s something comical and almost childlike about the Harvard kids and Arafat’s well-deserved final resting place. Yes I’m a secular Jew whose dad Rudolph Wihl, one of the Dunera Boys was held at Hay by the Australian governmen, yes I volunteered in ’67 as a teenager, yes my family were Holcaust victims and survivors. But here you have international Jewry outraged that college kids would iconize Arafat, really a pig and a thief of a man by any rational standard, and not get equally outraged by people like Che Guevara, another icon, or Lenin or Marx or Stalin with more blood on their hands than Hitler. This silly (sorry) foaming at the mouth about minor insults is hard to take. If I were a Palestinian parent trying to send my children to college only to have them barred from returning, I would detest the government of Israel. Rather than focus on nonsense like kids mugging over a coward’s grave how about being heroic as Jews and being merciful where its realistic and letting that mercy reflect our own experience. I would have shot Arafat without compunction, but only as one of any number of Arab cowards who attack from the dark and in silence. Let people talk about these fatuous self-serving jerks, make t-shirts, hold rallies. So what. My grandmother was a founder of ORT, my grandfather a high ranking cavalry officer, Jewish, in the German army in WW1. They didn’t waste time with punks, either the Arafat kind or the college kid kind.
Cheers,
Bryan Wihl