Bush, Obama, Russia, EU and UN buried under Trump Landslide
President Trump has buried the Bush Roadmap and any lingering hope for the creation of a second Arab State (“the two-state solution”) – in addition to Jordan – in the territory designated under the 1922 Mandate for Palestine…writes David Singer.
This inevitability follows Trump’s failure at a White House joint press conference with Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu on 15 February to reaffirm the written commitments made by President Bush to Israel in his letter dated 14 April 2004 – overwhelmingly endorsed by the Congress by 502 votes to 12 (“Bush Congress-Endorsed Commitments”).
President Bush had been urged to do so just the day before by veteran US peace negotiator – Dennis Ross – who stated it would have:
“significant implications, both because it was recognising settlement blocs referred to in the letter as major population centres, but also because it said that no agreement can involve going back to the 1949 Armistice lines or the equivalent of June 4, 1967.”
Similar calls had also been made by:
- Michael Oren – Israel’s former Ambassador to Washington and currently Deputy Minister in Netanyahu’s Prime Minister’s office
- Tzipi Livni – former Israeli Foreign Minister who had led negotiations for Israel with the Palestinian Authority in the peace talks brokered by U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry from July 2013 until April 2014.
- Danny Ayalon – Former Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister
Former Israeli United Nations ambassador and until recently the Director General of Israel’s Foreign Ministry – Dore Gold – had been concerned as far back as 9 June 2009 that President Obama was not going to reaffirm the Bush Congress-Endorsed Commitments:
“For example, it still needs to be clarified whether the Obama administration feels bound by the April 14, 2004, Bush letter to Sharon on defensible borders and settlement blocs, which was subsequently ratified by large bipartisan majorities in both the US Senate (95-3) and the House of Representatives (407-9) on June 23-24, 2004. Disturbingly, on June 1, 2009, the State Department spokesman, Robert Wood, refused to answer repeated questions about whether the Obama administration viewed itself as legally bound by the Bush letter. It would be better to obtain earlier clarification of that point, rather than having both countries expend their energies over an issue that may not be the real underlying source of their dispute.”
Obama’s clarification never came.
Even Netanyahu – just before boarding a plane to see Obama in the White House in May 2011- had said he expected:
“to hear a reaffirmation from President Obama of American commitments made to Israel in 2004 which were overwhelmingly supported by both Houses of Congress.”
Netanyahu never received that affirmation then – nor did he from Trump now.
Their reasons however are very different.
Obama proceeded to trash those commitments made with one of America’s closest allies with disastrous consequences for America’s foreign policy, its reputation and integrity.
Trump however had difficulty in reaffirming all of Bush’s commitments because one of them stated:
“ the United States remains committed to my vision and to its implementation as described in the roadmap. The United States will do its utmost to prevent any attempt by anyone to impose any other plan”
Trump doesn’t like long negotiations without any deal – and Trump wants to cut a deal.
Trump has accordingly ditched the Bush two-state solution – endorsed by Russia, the European Union and the United Nations. It now joins the diplomatic graveyard housing other two-state solutions proposed by
- the 1937 Peel Commission
- the 1947 United Nations Partition Plan,
- the 1993 Oslo Accords and
- Israel in 2000/2001 and 2008.
The Arabs have missed yet another opportunity to end the 100 years old Arab-Jewish conflict.
David Singer is a Sydney Lawyer and Foundation Member of the International Analysts Network
People will always fail if they think that the best way of thinking is by comparing people with other people or themselves with themselves.NOBODY wants to be Obama; NOBODY can be Donald Trump. NOBODY has been or will be Bush. You see how the Leaders are deeply frustrated because they think comparing themselves with others?. Each person is unique. I wonder if these leaders and many intellectuals have ever learnt this lesson.
Well documented history of this saga David. Thankyou.
It is Australia’s foreign policy position that any settlement of the issues between the Arab and Israeli occupants of territory in the Middle East has to be decided by the parties in dispute. That makes utmost sense doesn’t it?
It may well be that following the many years of frustration on the part of the U.N., the U.S.A., and the Norwegians in trying to help!! President Trump has concluded that it is best to maintain a respectable distance from the matter and try a more innovative approach. He has, after all, seemingly thrown away the ‘normal’ political rule book!
Others have speculated that Israel herself is promoting a ‘break’ in proceedings because of her (almost) clandestine new friendship with those perceived to have a better chance of influencing Arabs than those outside the Arab family.