Barak: Hold elections by June to adopt two-state solution
Israel must hold elections by June if Israel is to have a chance to accept the Biden administration’s plan for a post-war Gaza Strip, former Prime Minister Ehud Barak argued on Tuesday in Twitter Space, a forum for live conversations on X.
Ehud Barak Photo by Gideon Markowicz/TPS on 23 February, 2023
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly rejected the U.S. proposal that the Palestinian Authority take over the Gaza Strip, saying he will not “replace Hamastan with Fatahstan“—an interim step leading to a Palestinian state.
Barak, however, views the U.S. proposal favourably, where Gaza would come under the rule of a “revitalised” P.A. with reconstruction efforts aided by moderate Arab states such as Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, along with NATO countries, all with America’s blessing.
“Israel is urgently required to be prepared at a later stage in this process of bringing the revitalised [Palestinian] Authority to Gaza and entering into a political process, whose goal is ultimately two states,” Barak said.
There’s only a small window of opportunity for Israel to accept the U.S. plan because the American proposal will require the approval of a majority of Congress, meaning some 15 Republican senators would need to support it, Barak said.
“There is no chance that after April or May such a thing could be passed during the American election [campaign], when [Donald] Trump or whoever will run for president. The Republicans will probably say, ‘We are not handing Biden any achievements,’” Barak argued.
Israel must go to elections soon, he argued, working under the assumption that elections would mean Netanyahu’s ouster. (Barak over the years has made no secret of his distaste for the current prime minister and has long sought his removal.)
He noted it takes about 100 days for Israel to hold elections and said therefore the decision needs to be made by the start of Passover (April 22) at the latest.
Barak repeatedly depicted Netanyahu as boxed in by the more far-right members of the coalition, Religious Zionism Party leader Bezalel Smotrich and Otzma Yehudit Party head Itamar Ben-Gvir.
“We have a short time to free Netanyahu and the country from the grip of Ben-Gvir and Smotrich,” he said in a typical comment.
JNS political commentator Caroline Glick, who brought attention to Barak’s comments on Twitter, described the former PM’s discourse as part of a “coordinated line of the whole Biden-administration- supported Israeli leftist insurgency.”
Glick has written of an alliance between the Biden administration and Israeli civil society groups led by retired IDF generals to oust Netanyahu.
One think tank, Mitvim—The Israeli Institute for Regional Foreign Policies, put together a working group led by Maj. Gen. (res.) Nimrod Sheffer to build a plan for establishing a Palestinian state after the war.
According to the minutes of the working group’s meetings, revealed by Israeli news site HaKol HaYehudi, when it understood that the Israeli public was firmly against a Palestinian state, it decided that American pressure would be needed to force Israel to yield.
“The Americans are the ones that need to lead, craft and manage the process,” the working group’s participants concluded. “The U.S. needs to implement policy steps that Israel won’t be able to veto.”
The U.S., Europe and the U.N. have ramped up criticism of Netanyahu as the war progresses. On Monday, NBC News reported that President Joe Biden is “venting his frustration” in private over Israel’s military tactics, naming “Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as the primary obstacle.”
“’He just feels like this is enough,’” one of the sources said of the views expressed by Biden. ‘It has to stop,’” NBC reported.
The U.S. has also offered carrots to try and tempt Netanyahu to accept its two-state solution, with Secretary of State Antony Blinken promising Saudi normalization in exchange for the prime minister’s support during a Jan. 18 visit to Israel.
Following Netanyahu’s rejection of that offer, Jewish Democrats in the U.S. House of Representatives on Jan. 19 criticised Netanyahu for his stance, signing onto a statement saying “a two-state solution is the path forward.”
Barak and his fellows should be in gaol. He will go down in history as the worst “leader” Israel has ever had. As for the Jewish Democrats, their Jewishness is microns deep – they lack any Jewish feeling or understanding.
You sound like a fascist saying democratically elected leaders should be gaoled. Barak was a good rational leader as PM of Israel..
Adrian Jackson, you sound like you don’t know what you’re talking about. It has already been recorded that at Ehud Barak initiative, Israel dissolved the security Buffer Zone between Israel and South Lebanon in 2000. Outcome: Hezbollah’s terror tunnels, hundreds of thousands of missiles aimed at Israel as well as another Oct 7 waiting to happen at any moment. The facts are that every IDF General who became Prime Minister has proved to be a political disaster. Rabin with his useless 1993 Oslo Accords where Yasser Araf was invited back from Tunisia where he sought refuge to establish his headquarters in Judea and Samaria. Then there was Ariel Sharon who gave away Gaza without so much as a security presence left.
I suggest you acquaint yourself with history before telling someone that he sounds like a fascist.
Typical comment by a Leftist Ashkenazi Jew – a former General and PM.
I am convinced that a large minority of Jews have some suicidal gene buried deep in their DNA.