A Muslim talks on Chanukah
Premier Allan lit the giant menorah accompanied by Rabbi Gabi Kaltmann, who organised the event.
People are worried about the rising tide of anti-Semitism. People are worried about social cohesion. And I am worried, too. I am worried because I see how far we have come and how much we have achieved together as a multicultural community. And I remember the wise words of ECCV founder and first Chairman – the great Jewish community leader Walter Lippmann – who warned that, without constructive engagement, Australia would find itself ‘polarized into a collection of unfriendly, separate subcultural groups.’ Walter Lippmann was right.
Our multicultural communities must remain strong – and be strong enough to keep engaging constructively with each other.”
There are times in life when we feel the weight of history- individually and collectively. I felt that weight in 2015 when I visited the Holy Land for the first time and – as the Australian-born son of a Muslim Lebanese father and a mother who was raised Syrian Orthodox Christian – walked the streets of Jerusalem.
Our Chinese community felt that weight in 2020 during those first fearful reactions to the COVID-19 pandemic. Our Ukrainian and Russian communities have felt that weight ever since war broke out in 2022. Our Hindu and Sikh communities felt that weight during the Khalistan referendum earlier this year. Our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community felt that weight during the Voice referendum.
We all felt that weight when we saw neo-Nazis parading outside State Parliament earlier this year – or down the streets of Ballarat last week. And our Australian Jewish and Muslim communities are feeling that weight the right now. Our Jewish Community has felt that weight since those horrendous attacks of October 7. And is grappling with the rise of antisemitism in Australia.
Moments like these test us as people and communities. They test us because they apply pressure to our principles – and we find out what we really believe. That is the weight of history. The Ethnic Communities’ Council of Victoria was made for moments like this. Almost 50 years ago a generation of men and women who survived the Depression, World War Two and the Cold War came together to forge our organisation – Among them were people who survived the Holocaust, people who knew what it was like to be a refugee, people who experienced the White Australia policy.
What defines us as Australians is our ability to accept difference. Different backgrounds, different faiths, different languages, different sexuality, different cultures: one Australia. My point. We are all Australians. And, as Australians, we cannot let current international events undermine the social cohesion and harmony that define and benefit our multicultural communities.
The scenes we saw a few weeks ago in Caulfield and the Neo-Nazi March in Ballarat we saw last Sunday are to be condemned. Those scenes are not who we are. That is why we must stand together as Australians. We must stand together against the rising tide of anti-Semitism. We must stand together against the rising tide of Islamophobia. We must unequivocally condemn acts of hatred and violence by whoever they’re done by. We must not allow fear and prejudice to overshadow the principles that define and protect us as Australians.
And I am proud to stand here as an Australian Muslim today with Victoria’s Jewish community to celebrate the festival of lights and the differences that make our nation so great… With the lighting of each Chanukkah candle, let’s keep hoping for a better future and standing together.”
As the CEO of the ECCV and a Muslim I’m proud to have celebrated the Festival of Lights with our Jewish community and the differences that make our nation so great. The Festival of Lights is an important reminder that even in the darkest times, our multicultural communities can come together as Australians.”
Is this the first public statement of support for Jews and condemnation of events of October 7 in Australia by a person publicly declaring he is of the Muslim faith?
The serpent has many attributs and names,indeed.
Dear Pinchas,with the utmost respect,it is time to let go.
Arab Palestinians did not think,order or execute the final solution.
The Nazi Germany ,did.
The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was pretty interested in it! And he had a few worthwhile visits with Hitler in Germany. It wasn’t long before all those pogroms in Arab states followed – Iraq, Yemen, Syria – and by 1949 we had around 750,000 fleeing their homes where their families had been for generations.
Not sure Mia why you make ref to the final solution
Time to let go what exactly?
I am pointing out deafening silence from Muslim clerics who I would have expected would stand up and state that the acts of Oct 7 do not represent the Islamic Faith etc…it took around a week for them to state this wrt 9-11 tragedy- but it has been many weeks and nothing at all??
Concerns me greatly – little hope for the average moderate Moslem thinker to have balanced information when their leadership does not speak out – what do we make of this silence – does it = agreement with what has happened in Israel and eqally what is taking place in Gaza where all suffering / destruction is due to Hamas?
It is good to hear a Muslim leader speak out about the hate speech that has happened on the streets of Australia with the call of genocide against the Jewish people. In these difficult times we need a voice of balance from every quater. Thank you for the balance.
One doesn’t need to be a leader of anything to state the obvious.
The tone sounds,elitist,superior,patronising and not kind.
As if,Australians (all of ´US ´) would witness like bystanders,despicable things and NOT VOICE THE HORROR.
The word balance,means equilibrium,upright and steady.
Any kind of violence,directed towards any human,is not ok.